How Does Coronavirus Affect Contracts?
The global Coronavirus Pandemic (COVID-19) has sent uncertainty rippling through businesses and households around the globe. As civil litigators, we are keenly aware that such monumental events can – and often do – affect contractual relationships entered into before this pandemic took hold. However, the extent of this is open for debate. The answer lies somewhere in the front line battles being wages over this question right now. Perhaps the most visible example of this is the test case involving the venture capital firm Sycamore Partners and L Brands planned sale of Victoria’s Secret. We’ll take a look at this ongoing litigation to better understand how Courts are likely to handle the enforcement of contracts that are impacted by the Coronavirus pandemic.
Speak to a Lawyer today
Fill out the contact form below and a lawyer will contact you to discuss your case.
The Victoria’s Secret Acquisition
In February, after extensive negotiations, the venture capital group Sycamore Partners announced that it would acquire a 55% interest in Victoria’s Secret lingerie, Victoria’s Secret Beauty and the Pink Brand. The estimated value of the acquisition was $1.1 Billion Dollars.
Sycamore Partners is no stranger to these type of acquisitions. It has a history of purchasing distressed retailers, including Hot Topic, Talbots, Staples and Coldwater Creek.
This deal was announced on February 20th, 2020, during the early days of the Coronavirus pandemic. In mid-march, the retail chain announced that it would close all retail locations in the U.S. and Canada. Shortly after this announcement, the retail chain further suspended all online sales through the month of March, stating in a press release that it was doing so to protect against the spread of the virus. This decision was unprecedented at the time, as most retailers were moving operations to the internet – not closing them down.
Sycamore Partners Announces $1.1 Billion Dollar Acquisition
World Health Organization Declares Pandemic
L Brands Closes All Retail Locations
L Brands Ceases All Online Shopping
As the pandemic raged on, the fate of the Sycamore Partners acquisition became increasingly uncertain. In late April, Sycamore Partners filed a suit in a Delaware Chancery Court (Case Number 2020-0297). This move sent L Brands stock plummeting some 20%.
In its filing, Sycamore took issue with specific actions taken by L Brands, including furloughing most Victoria’s Secret employees and cutting the salaries of senior employees, as well as the company’s missed April rent payments for U.S. retail stores and its “stock of merchandise of greatly diminished value.”
In essence, the suit seeks a “a declaration that the termination of its agreement to acquire a majority interest in the Victoria’s Secret Business1 of L Brands is valid.” The complaint specifically alleges that “L Brands has breached its covenants in the parties’ Transaction Agreement” and “has caused several of its representations and warranties in the Transaction Agreement to become false.” Perhaps most interestingly for the future of contract litigation in the Cornavirus era, the complaint asserts that:
“The spread of a novel coronavirus (“COVID-19”) provides no relief to L Brands under the terms of the Transaction Agreement that Plaintiff seeks to enforce.”
For it’s part, L Brands said in a statement that it believed Sycamore’s attempt to terminate the acquisition was “invalid,” and that it planned to “vigorously defend the lawsuit” and work toward closing the deal.
In response, the company filed a 32-page response containing counterclaims seeking to force Sycamore Partners to complete the deal – citing the pandemic as a justifiable excuse for performing certain contractual obligations.
A private equity firm acknowledged the "international tragedy and health emergency," but said it didn't excuse actions taken by the lingerie chain's parent company, including closing stores.
While it is unclear how this situation will ultimately be resolved, the outcome is being watched very carefully – as it is expected to have a ripple effect on contracts throughout the Country. In many ways, this case if the first big flashpoint for the way contract excuse will operate in the post-pandemic world.
Need a Civil Lawyer?
Our Litigators Are Standing By
Dennis E. Sawan
Licensed in Ohio and Florida
Dennis P. Sawan
Licensed in Ohio and Georgia
Christopher A. Sawan
Licensed in Ohio and Michigan
Contact an Attorney today to discuss your case.
Request A Call
discover our latest Articles
Probate for Personal Injury Settlements of Minors in Ohio If a minor is injured in Ohio, a probate court is going to have to approve
Minerva Middle School Settles Wrestler’s Injury Claim In Stark county, the Minerva Middle School was recently sued after a wrestler was allegedly injured, traumatized, and
When Is Incitement Not Protected Free Speech? The First Amendment protects a near limitless amount of political discourse, opinion and conjecture – but the right
7 High-Profile Celebrity Car Crashes As Car Accident Lawyers, we know that a car accident can happen to anyone – at any time. This includes
Writs of Prohibition in Ohio Writs of prohibition in the State of Ohio are extraordinary remedies that involve an exercise of judicial power that is
Supreme Court decision paves way for big change to Sovereign Immunity law In the month of December, the United States Supreme Court issued an important
Car Accident Lawyers
Ohio Car Accident Lawyers
Toledo Ohio Car Accident Lawyers
Columbus Ohio Car Accident Lawyers
Cleveland Ohio Car Accident Lawyers
Georgia Car Accident Lawyers
Savannah Georgia Car Accident Lawyers
Florida Car Accident Lawyers
Jacksonville Florida Car Accident Lawyers
Michigan Car Accident Lawyers
Personal Injury Lawyers
Ohio Personal Injury Lawyers
Toledo Ohio Personal Injury Lawyers
Columbus Ohio Personal Injury Lawyers
Cleveland Ohio Personal Injury Lawyers
Georgia Personal Injury Lawyers
Savannah Georgia Personal Injury Lawyers
Florida Personal Injury Lawyers
Jacksonville Florida Personal Injury Lawyers
Michigan Personal Injury Lawyers